Data as Records: PRA Disclosure of Database Information – MRSC
Eligible government agencies can use our free one-on-one inquiry service.
With one call or click you can get a personalized answer from one of our trusted attorneys, policy consultants, or finance experts!
Ask MRSC
VIEW MORE
VIEW MORE
VIEW MORE
Data as Records: PRA Disclosure of Database Information November 14, 2022
How Can Local Governments Celebrate the Holidays? November 9, 2022
Care and Feeding of Your Library Collection Policy November 7, 2022
VIEW MORE BLOG POSTS
MRSC E-Newsletters
MRSC Insight Blog
MRSC Quarterly Print Newsletter
Local Governments In The News
Landlord/Seller Disclosure Requirements
VIEW MORE
Upcoming Trainings – Attend our live webinars, virtual workshops, and in-person trainings to learn about key local government issues!
Digging Into Public Works – In-person regional forums and training resources for public works staff and local contractors
VIEW MORE
On-Demand Webinars – Watch pre-recorded versions of our recent webinars, at your own convenience.
PRA/OPMA E-Learning Courses – Free video courses for city/town elected officials on the Public Records Act (PRA) and Open Public Meetings Act (OPMA).
VIEW TRAINING CALENDAR
www.mrscrosters.org
VIEW MORE
VIEW MORE
Public Records Act
Open Public Meetings Act
Purchasing and Contracting
Budgeting
American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA)
Coronavirus (COVID-19) Resources
VIEW MORE
Economic Development
Environment
Finance
Governance
Legal
Management
VIEW MORE
Parks and Recreation
Personnel
Planning
Public Safety
Public Works and Utilities
Transportation
VIEW MORE
November 14, 2022 by Sarah Doar
Category: Public Records Act
One of the more seemingly complex public records request types are those that seek information held within a database. There are several questions we are often asked, and I hope my answers below will assist in unravelling this digital conundrum.
Are databases even public records at all?
First, let us agree on a few terms. A database is an organized collection of data stored and accessed electronically. In turn, data or datum, are the individual pieces of information stored within the database.
A database management system (DMS) is the visual interface that organizes the data, translates the data from zeros and ones, and allows users to access and view the data in a manner they can understand. A DMS can be incredibly sophisticated, with multiple databases of information and the ability to link, manipulate, and analyze data, or it can be a simple Excel spreadsheet. Both are database management systems.
What would be the analog version? For those of a certain age, a database management system is roughly the same as a library card catalog. Each card is a piece of data, all the cards together are the database, and the cabinet that keeps everything organized, cross-referenced, and accessible to library patrons is the DMS. Without the cabinet, you’d be faced with a pile of cards and no way to find what you are looking for.
Let us apply this analogy now to the Public Records Act, Chapter 42.56 RCW (PRA). The PRA defines a “public record” as:
any writing containing information relating to the conduct of government or the performance of any governmental or proprietary function prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics.
Each of those cards in the card catalogue is a writing that contains information, and it happens to be in paper form. For databases, each piece of data in the DMS is a writing that contains information, and it happens to be in digital form.
So, if that piece of data in the database pertains to the conduct of government and it was prepared, owned, used, or retained by the local agency, then, yes, it is a public record. But it is the data itself, and not the database management system, that is the public record.
How do you disclose data in a database?
Under the PRA, we are obligated to disclose the data in the database but not necessarily to provide unfettered access to that data. At the same time, we cannot somehow turn over a bunch of zeros and ones and think that we have met our obligations under the PRA — we must provide the data in a form that the requestor can actually read.
There are several ways to do this. Some jurisdictions simply provide public access to the relevant DMS, although access is limited to view only. Examples of this include a county assessor’s property tax database, a city’s planning and development permit records online portal, or a clerk’s website that posts all the council’s agendas and meeting minutes.
However, in many situations, the DMS is a part of a public employee’s daily workflow, one which is constantly being updated with new activities and may contain information that is subject to an exemption or prohibition against disclosure such that is inappropriate to provide the public with unfettered access.
If you are lucky, your DMS allows you to run reports that extract the responsive data and present it in a form that you are then able to provide to the requestor. Alternatively, you have to consider providing customized access to the database that will limit the requestor’s access to only the data they are entitled to.
Isn’t running a report creating a new record?
We do consider the results of extracting data from a database into a new spreadsheet or word document to be the creation of a new record that is itself fully subject to the PRA. But sometimes, especially when it comes to databases which you often cannot provide unrestricted public access to, that approach makes the most practical sense.
Creation of a new record is not addressed in the Public Records Act, but there is case law that states agencies are not under an obligation to create records for a requestor. See Citizens For Fair Share v. State Dep't of Corrections, 117 Wn. App. 411, 435, 72 P.3d 206, 219 (2003) ("the law does not require creation of nonexistent records in response to a public records disclosure request”).
The Attorney General PRA Model Rule (WAC 44-14-04003(6)) states that an agency has discretion whether to create a public record:
. . . The decision to create a new record is left to the discretion of the agency. With respect to databases, for example, there is not always a simple dichotomy between producing an existing record and creating a new record. In addition, an agency may decide to provide a customized service and if so, assess a customized service charge for the actual costs of staff technology expertise needed to prepare data compilations, or when such customized access services are not used by the agency for other business purposes. RCW 42.56.120.
If the agency is considering creating a new record instead of disclosing the underlying records, or creating new records from a database, it should obtain the consent of the requestor to ensure that the requestor is not actually seeking the underlying records, and describe any customized service charges that may apply.
According to RCW 42.56.100, your agency must provide the “fullest assistance” to inquirers requesting public records, but this does not mean your agency must create a new record upon request. That being said, if your database is itself a compilation of independent records, such as scanned and uploaded records, I would consider the downloading of a previously scanned record akin to making a copy and not generating a new record.
What if our DMS is not set up to allow for the extraction of data, such as to run reports?
You may need to get creative. One brute force method is to take screenshots of the DMS displaying the requested information, although this would not work if the requestor is seeking the data in its native format, nor would it work for a visually impaired requestor. Your other option is to consider providing customized access.
What is customized access, and can we charge for that?
In addition to the regular copying charges that an agency can impose under RCW 42.56.120, paragraph (3) allows an agency to include a “customized service charge.”
A customized service charge may only be imposed if the agency estimates that the request would require the use of information technology expertise to prepare data compilations, or provide customized electronic access services when such compilations and customized access services are not used by the agency for other agency purposes.
Examples may include working with your software developer or IT staff to run a new, customized report that extracts data from the database, developing a new user interface that has restricted functionality, or purchasing a new user software license to allow the requestor direct access.
What if we don’t control the database or database management system?
A record is a public record if it is “prepared, owned, used, OR retained” by the public agency, so even if the agency no longer has control of the record — i.e., did not “retain” the record — if the agency created the record or used the record in the course of public business, it is a public record subject to disclosure.
I am aware of several situations where local agencies access and/or upload information to databases controlled by other private or public entities. Regardless of where that data now lives, local agencies are obligated to make it available to the public upon request. It is not enough to simply direct requestors to the third party.
Any agency that uses third-party databases should review the contract or terms of service for those databases to ensure that the agency has a process for requesting copies of records contained in the database from the vendor.
No. While many agencies make records available online in the hope that members of the public will be able to self-serve and access the records they seek without submitting a records request, once an individual does submit a request, all of an agency’s obligations under the PRA come into effect.
In describing the specific methods by which an agency can respond to a public records request, RCW 42.56.520(1)(b) authorizes the agency to provide “an internet address and link on the agency’s website to the specific records requested.” (Emphasis added). Providing a link to a database that requires the requestor perform the search themselves does not satisfy this obligation. Of course, an agency can inform the requestor that, in the future, they can search the public database themselves and avoid any delay in receiving a response.
Wow, it can get pretty complicated. What if we need more guidance?
You are not alone! MRSC has lots of information available on our Public Records Act topic pages. If your question is not addressed there or you wish to contact one of our consultants directly, eligible government agencies can Ask MRSC.
MRSC is a private nonprofit organization serving local governments in Washington State. Eligible government agencies in Washington State may use our free, one-on-one Ask MRSC service to get answers to legal, policy, or financial questions.
Sarah Doar joined MRSC in September 2018.
Most recently, she served as a Civil Deputy Prosecuting Attorney for Island County. At Island County, Sarah advised on many aspects of government business, including compliance with public record and opening meeting laws. She also defended the County in Growth Management Act and Land Use litigation. Prior to moving to Washington, Sarah practiced land use, environmental, and appellate law in Florida for over eight years.
Sarah holds a B.A. in Biology from Case Western Reserve University and a J.D. with a certificate in environmental and land use law from Florida State University College of Law.
VIEW ALL POSTS BY Sarah Doar
Receive MRSC's latest articles and analysis through our Weekly Insights e-newsletter.
BLOG
Court of Appeals Reverses Large Public Records Act Penalty Imposed on University of Washington
IN THE NEWS
County auditors have received an unprecedented amount of public records requests since the 2020 election, and it’s likely just the beginning
ASK MRSC
If a staff member installs and uses a cloud-based communications tool like Microsoft Teams on their personal cell phone, is it possible…
PUBLICATIONS
Knowing the Territory – Basic Legal Guidelines for Washington City, County and Special District Officials
TOPICS
Managing Electronic Records
Subscribe to E-Newsletters
MRSC Insight Blog
LEARN MORE ABOUT NEWSLETTERS
www.mrscrosters.org
VIEW MORE
